Why “Time” Isn’t the Best Measure of Effective Low Impact Strength Exercises (And What to Do Instead)
- Amanda Boike
- Dec 22, 2025
- 6 min read
By Amanda Boike Fitness
If you’ve ever done a 60-minute workout that felt like… mostly rearranging dumbbells and choosing a playlist (relatable), you already know the secret: Minutes don’t equal results. Dose equals results.
And effective strength training, especially low impact strength exercises, is all about the dose.
Time is a container. Your muscles care about the stimulus.
Cardio guidelines often talk in minutes. Strength training? It's about sets, effort, and progression.
Here’s the dead-simple reason: your muscles don’t have a stopwatch. They respond to tension + enough challenging reps repeated consistently over time. (Source: American Heart Association) professional.heart.org
So yes, you can do a long workout that’s under-dosed.And you can do a short workout that’s chef’s-kiss effective.
The “minutes” myth (and why it’s extra sneaky for low-impact training)
Low-impact doesn’t mean low-effort. It means lower joint irritation, smarter mechanics, and better repeatability.
But because low-impact sessions can feel less dramatic (fewer burpees, less “I am a sweaty puddle”), people assume they “didn’t do enough” unless the workout was long.
Cue the guilt spiral. Cue the overdoing it. Cue the “why do my knees hate me” subplot.
Instead: let’s swap the stopwatch for a scoreboard.
Your scoreboard for effective strength training: 5 things to track instead of time
1) Hard sets per week (your #1 strength metric)
A hard set is a set taken close enough to challenge you—think RPE ~7–9 (you could maybe do 1–3 more reps with good form). (Source: Currier et al., BJSM) PubMed+1
Starter target (most busy humans):
4-8 hard sets per major muscle group per week (glutes/legs, push muscles, pull muscles)
Build toward 6–12 as recovery allows (There's no rush toward this numebr- this can be worked toward over a period of years.)
Why the range? Because more weekly work often helps… until you hit diminishing returns. (Source: Pelland et al., 2025) PubMed
Translation: You don’t need marathon sessions. You need enough quality sets, repeated weekly.
2) Effort: RPE or reps-in-reserve (RIR)
Let’s make this practical:
RPE 6: “I could do ~4 more reps.”
RPE 7: “I could do ~3 more reps.”
RPE 8: “I could do ~2 more reps.”
RPE 9: “I could do ~1 more rep.”
RPE 10: “Nope. Done. End scene.”
For most low-impact strength work, living around RPE 7–9 is the sweet spot: effective, sustainable, and less “wrecked.” (Source: Currier et al., BJSM) PubMed+1
3) Progression (the receipts)
Progress isn’t always adding weight. It can be:
+1 rep with the same dumbbells
Same reps, but better control (slower lower, no wobble)
More range of motion (deeper squat to a box)
Less joint crankiness afterward (major win)
Track one “win” per exercise per week. That’s it.
4) Exercise selection that respects your joints (biomechanics > bravado)
Low-impact strength exercises shine when you pick moves that deliver high muscle load with lower joint stress.
Think:
Box squat / sit-to-stand (quad + glute load, controlled depth)
Hip hinge patterns (Hip thrusts, deadlift variations)
Supported rows (back work without low-back grumpiness)
Incline push-ups or dumbbell floor press (pressing without shoulder drama)
Step-downs (life-proof knees and hips for stairs)
This is where a physics-based coach earns their keep: leverage, load placement, and range, so you get the stimulus without the flare-up spiral.
5) Consistency (the underrated superpower)
Public health orgs are clear: strength work belongs in your week, not in occasional heroic bursts.
Two quick receipts:
“Adults also need 2 days of muscle-strengthening activity each week.” (Source: CDC) CDC
“Muscle-strengthening activities should be done… on 2 or more days a week.” (Source: WHO) World Health Organization
Consistency beats occasional intensity.; especially if you’re peri/menopausal, busy, or managing aches. (Source: American Heart Association) professional.heart.org
A simple formula that beats “How long was it?”
The 2–3–8 Rule (beginner-friendly, wildly effective)
2–3 days/week strength
3–5 exercises/session
8–12 reps per set at RPE 7–9
2–3 sets per exercise
This lines up with both public health guidance and strength programming research: you can get strong without living in the gym. (Source: CDC; Currier et al., BJSM) CDC+2PubMed+2
Proof that “short + hard enough” works for effective strength training (especially for midlife women)
A 2024 randomized trial in menopausal women used a twice-weekly, minimal-dose program (2 sets of 8–12 reps on a few exercises) and still improved strength in 4 weeks. (Source: Scientific Reports, 2024) Nature
And broader reviews show “minimal dose” approaches can meaningfully increase strength for people who feel time-crunched. (Source: Nuzzo, 2024) PMC
A 30-minute low-impact strength session that earns its place on your calendar
Warm-up (5 min)
1 minute easy marching + arm swings
6–8 bodyweight hinges
6–8 box squats
6–8 scapular retractions (stand tall, pull shoulders “into back pockets”)
Strength (20 min) Do 2–3 rounds. Rest ~60–120 seconds between sets.
Dumbbell Hip Thrust - 8–12 reps @ RPE 7–9
Box squat - 8–12 reps @ RPE 7–9
One-arm row (supported) - 8–12/side @ RPE 7–9
Incline push-up or DB floor press - 6–12 reps @ RPE 7–9
Finish (5 min)
Carry (farmer carry or suitcase carry) 2–3 x 30–45 seconds
Easy breathing + gentle hip flexor opener
Why this works: you’re tracking hard sets and effort, not trying to win “longest workout.” (Source: Currier et al., BJSM; Pelland et al., 2025) PubMed+2British Journal of Sports Medicine+2
Measuring progress without obsessing over time
Use this 30-second post-workout check-in:
Did I hit RPE 7–9 on my main sets?
How many hard sets did I get for legs/push/pull today?
What’s one micro-progression I made (rep, load, control, ROM)?
Do I feel “worked, not wiped” 2 hours later? (That’s sustainability.)
If you want a number: give yourself a weekly “strength score”:
Green: 2 sessions/week (minimum effective consistency)
Gold: 3 sessions/week (sweet spot for many)
Platinum: 4 sessions/week (if recovery is solid)
Chicago note: If you’re hiring help, what does it usually cost?
For in home personal trainer Chicago support, pricing varies based on experience, travel time, and specialization.
Marketplaces commonly cite ~$40–$100/hour as a broad U.S. range. (Source: Thumbtack, Oct 2025) Thumbtack
A Chicago-specific local estimate often lands around $60–$120/hour, with specialists higher. (Source: Chicago Strength In Motion, Apr 2025) Chicago Strength In Motion
If those numbers don’t match perfectly, it’s usually because marketplace averages include newer trainers and remote/virtual options, while local “specialist” rates skew higher- so for budgeting, I’d trust the broader range first, then refine by specialty. Thumbtack+1
FAQ (People Also Ask)
Is a 20-minute workout enough to get stronger?
Yes, if you hit enough hard sets close to fatigue and repeat it weekly. Minimal-dose research and trials show strength can improve with short, consistent sessions. (Source: Nuzzo, 2024; Scientific Reports, 2024) PMC+1
What matters more: workout duration or intensity?
For strength adaptations, effort + volume + progression matter more than duration. Time helps you fit the dose, but time alone isn’t the dose. (Source: Currier et al., BJSM; Pelland et al., 2025) PubMed+2British Journal of Sports Medicine+2
What is RPE and how do I use it?
RPE is your perceived effort. Aim most working sets at RPE 7–9 (1–3 reps left with clean form). It’s a simple way to standardize effort across different exercises and weeks. (Source: Currier et al., BJSM) PubMed+1
How many sets per week do I need per muscle group?
Start around 6–10 hard sets/week per major muscle group, then build as recovery allows. Research suggests dose-response relationships exist, with diminishing returns at higher volumes. (Source: Pelland et al., 2025; Currier et al., BJSM) PubMed+2PubMed+2
Do low impact strength exercises still build muscle?
Absolutely. “Low impact” refers to lower joint pounding, not “easy.” If you train close enough to fatigue and progress over time, low-impact training can be highly effective. (Source: American Heart Association) professional.heart.org
How close to failure should I train?
Most people do great at 1–3 reps in reserve for primary sets (RPE 7–9). You don’t need to hit true failure constantly to make progressm and you’ll usually recover better if you don’t. (Source: Currier et al., BJSM) PubMed+1
What’s a good strength plan for peri/menopausal women?
A strong baseline is 2–3 days/week full-body strength with joint-friendly moves and progressive overload. Even low-volume, twice-weekly approaches have improved strength in menopausal women in short timeframes. (Source: Scientific Reports, 2024) Nature
How do I measure progress if I don’t track time?
Track: hard sets/week, RPE/RIR, reps/load, and consistency. Your muscles “see” that better than minutes. (Source: Pelland et al., 2025) PubMed
How much does an in-home personal trainer in Chicago cost?
A practical planning range is $60–$120/hour for many experienced coaches, with broad marketplace ranges often cited around $40–$100/hour. (Source: Chicago Strength In Motion; Thumbtack) Chicago Strength In Motion+1
What’s the best “minimum effective dose” strength routine?
If you’re starting from zero, aim for 2 days/week, a few big moves, 2–3 sets, and push sets to RPE 7–9. Minimal-dose research supports meaningful strength gains with small, consistent doses. (Source: Nuzzo, 2024) PMC
If you want the shortcut: make it personal (Chicago + online)
If you’re done guessing and want a plan built around your body, schedule, equipment, and joints, working with an in home personal trainer Chicago (or an online coach who programs like one) can turn “I hope this works” into “oh- this is what effective feels like.”
Comments